Our Team

United by One Goal: Protecting Your Property Investments
and Ensuring a Smooth Closing Experience

Clearwater Office:

Joseph Cash

Owner

Megan Willoughby

Business Development

Frank Cruz

Senior Closer - Branch Manager

Amy Marzano

Licensed Title Agent

Justin Phipps

Processor

Angela Novello

Remote Processor

Megan Willoughby

Business Development

Lerin Hukill

Business Development

Corinne Cook

Lead Processor, Closing Coordinator

Eric Johnson

Licensed Title Agent

Tampa Office:

Kristin Campbell

Westchase Office Manager

Christina Swan

Licensed Title Agent

Justin Phipps

Processor

Tina O’Connor

Licensed Title Agent

Brian Mensching

Closer

Buying, Selling, or Refinancing?

Let us handle your closing.

Whether you’re buying your first home, selling, or refinancing — we make your closing smooth, secure, and worry-free.

Talk to your lender or agent about your options, then let them know you’d like First Title Source to handle your closing — we’ll take care of the rest. We manage every step from start to finish with efficiency, security, and care.

Tip: If you've purchased or refinanced before, you may qualify for a re-issue credit—which can help reduce your closing costs.

727-399-6977